Looking at the classic Valentine’s Day treats, it’s clear that cookies hold a special place in our hearts. They’re the perfect symbol of love and affection, and nothing says ‘I care’ like a freshly baked batch. With their delicious flavors and adorable shapes, these sweet treats are sure to bring a smile to your loved one’s face. From classic sugar cookies to decadent chocolate chip and red velvet creations, this collection of over 25 Valentine’s Day cookie recipes has something for everyone.
Whether you’re planning a romantic dinner, a cozy breakfast in bed, or just want to surprise your sweetheart with a sweet treat, these cookies are sure to impress. Bake them into heart-shaped cutouts, package them in cute containers, or simply serve them up on a platter – whatever you choose, they’re guaranteed to be swoon-worthy.
Heath Bar Cookies
Just one bite into these heavenly cookies and you’ll be transported to a world of bliss. Inspired by the timeless classic, Heath bars, they’re reimagined as chewy treats that capture the essence of those beloved chocolatey confections. With chunks of crunchy toffee scattered throughout, they offer a delightful combination that’s sure to sweep you off your feet – making them an excellent starting point for anyone looking to fall head over heels in love.
Valentine’s Day Heart Sugar Cookies
Join the ranks of cookie enthusiasts who use their baked goods to express their affection by making these deliciously sweet treats. The key to their romance lies in the generous amount of thick sugar icing that tops basic butter cookies – which, of course, are shaped into hearts for an extra touch of whimsy.
As you spread this tasty glaze onto your cookie creations, feel free to get creative and pipe on personalized messages like ‘Be Mine’ or ‘Cutiepie,’ making each one a unique and heartfelt gift.
Valentine’s Frosted Sugar Cookies
Obtaining an elegant dessert for your loved one doesn’t necessarily mean breaking the bank or spending hours in the kitchen. These scaled-up Valentine’s butter cookies are a classic treat that can be easily customized with a few simple ingredients and creative touches. By using a basic vanilla butter dough, you’ll have a solid foundation for your mini-heart treats, which can then be topped with a smooth buttercream frosting.
Add a splash of pink and red food coloring to give them an extra pop of color and you’ll be left with a beautifully presented platter of gorgeously bright mini-hearts that are sure to impress.
Valentine Sandwich Cookies
Wrapped in romance, sandwich cookies become an even more delightful treat. This recipe adds a touch of whimsy to the classic cookie by inserting a layer of pastel-pink buttercream between layers of chocolate hearts. The result is a taste experience that’s reminiscent of homemade Oreos, perfect for indulging at parties or as a sweet finale to a romantic dinner.
Red Velvet White Chocolate Chip Cookies
Highlighting their irresistible texture and appearance, these stunning cookies have won the hearts of many. They boast an appealing bright red hue and are generously speckled with succulent chunks of creamy white chocolate, creating a visually stunning presentation.
Linzer Cookies
Create a romantic atmosphere this Valentine’s Day by baking a batch of Linzer cookies with your loved one. These classic shortbread rounds are not only easy to make but also incredibly fun to decorate. Traditional heart shapes are always a hit, but feel free to get creative and use cut-outs that reflect the couple’s personal style. The best part? These buttery treats are so delicious that they’ll become a staple in your household long after February 14th has passed.
With their delicate almond flour dough and hint of citrus zest, Linzer cookies are the perfect combination of elegance and simplicity.
Ghirardelli Chocolate Chip Cookies
Often associated with romance and luxury, chocolate is a popular choice for special occasions. These decadent yet straightforward cookies are made with chunks of high-end chocolate, such as Ghiradelli, to create a rich and intensely cocoa-flavored taste experience. Fortunately, Ghirardelli isn’t the only option; any premium dark chocolate will yield equally impressive results in this flexible and uncomplicated recipe.
Double Chocolate Cherry Cookies
Juxtaposed against the cliché that chocolate is an aphrodisiac, these rich cocoa cookies are sure to spark some passion. With their dense, fudgy texture and intensely chocolatey flavor, they’re the perfect indulgence. But take it up a notch by serving them with a maraschino cherry nestled in the soft center and drizzle with a thick chocolate fudge sauce for an extra decadent treat.
Mexican Wedding Cookies
Understanding that Valentine’s Day is the most romantic time of year, couples often choose this day to pop the question. In fact, many people consider it the best day to propose. To get a head start on wedding preparations, consider serving traditional wedding cookies at your next nuptial celebration. These delicious treats are a staple in South American culture and perfect for festive occasions.
Known as butterballs or round shortbread cookies, they live up to their name with their rich, crumbly texture and abundance of buttery flavor. Their irresistible taste is sure to have you reaching for another – but be warned, it’s easy to devour the whole batch!
Madeleines
Generally speaking, making madeleines can be an intimidating task for inexperienced cooks due to their delicate nature. However, this simple recipe is surprisingly easy to follow, requiring only a few straightforward steps to produce perfectly baked pastries. Rather than getting flustered on Valentine’s Day, take some time to whisk together the buttery batter and pour it into a madeleine pan.
Simply pop it in the oven, and wait for your golden brown treats to emerge, ready to be enjoyed warm and fresh from the oven. You’ll wonder where these delightful pastries have been all your life!
French Macarons
Here’s a perfect recipe for French macarons that’s ideal for beginners, so don’t let fear of failure hold you back. Throughout this guide, we’ll walk you through each step, providing valuable tips and techniques along the way. With practice, you’ll master the art of making these exquisite sandwich cookies, which not only look stunning but also melt in your mouth with a delightful balance of crunch on the outside and softness within.
French macarons are an impressive treat to serve at any gathering or special occasion.
Vanilla Tea Cake Cookies
Among the most understated yet satisfying treats, these humble vanilla cookies prove that simplicity can indeed be key. The absence of elaborate ingredients or techniques belies their rich, buttery flavor and pleasing texture, which is both crispy and crumbly at the same time. Perfect for Valentine’s Day or any holiday occasion, these easy-to-make cookies are sure to become a treasured favorite – save this recipe now and you’ll be glad you did!
Kitchen Sink Cookies
Everybody knows that kitchen sink cookies may not have the most romantic-sounding name, but they’re an excellent option for novice bakers. In reality, this cookie recipe has gained immense popularity as a copycat of Panera Bread’s chewy chocolate chip cookie formula. By definition, kitchen sink cookies allow you to get creative with various add-ins once you’ve mastered the basic dough.
Nuts, dried fruit, orange zest, mini-marshmallows – and many other ingredients can be experimented with in this versatile recipe.
Meringue Cookies
Yielding elegance and sophistication, meringues are the perfect cookie to impress your loved ones on Valentine’s Day. Not only do they look stunning with their airy texture, but they’re also infused with a subtle hint of vanilla for added flavor. To give them an extra touch, try adding a drop of red food coloring to create a romantic pink hue that will surely make your day memorable.
Red Velvet Crinkle Cookies
Crinkle cookies have a special place in my heart, not just during Christmas, but now, I’m willing to make an exception for Valentine’s Day with this stunning recipe. The vibrant red color is more than just visually appealing; it’s also complemented by the rich flavors of cocoa and vanilla within the soft, buttery crumb. However, it’s the generous addition of white chocolate chips that truly sets these decadent treats apart, making them a delightful indulgence for sweet-toothed couples.
Dulce de Leche Sandwich Cookies
Wrapped around my heart, dulce de leche has a special place – I could (and sometimes do) eat it straight from the jar with a spoon. The winning combination of butter, caramel, treacle, and syrupy sweetness is undeniably irresistible. But, as much as I’d love to indulge in this sweet treat unapologetically, I’m aware that doing so isn’t exactly socially acceptable.
So, here’s a recipe that offers a delightful compromise – you’ll still get to experience all that rich goodness, but now it’s spread in a thick, gooey layer between crumbly butter cookies.
Peanut Butter Blossoms
Just one bite into these decadent peanut butter blossoms, and the delightful surprise of the hidden chocolate kiss reveals itself. This delectable treat combines the usual soft cookie texture with an abundance of peanut butter and brown sugar to create a richly flavored, chewy delight.
As they cool from the oven, dropping a chocolate kiss in the center is the finishing touch, made even more festive by adding sprinkles for those who want to add an extra layer of fun to their Valentine’s Day treat.
Heart Chocolate Chip Cookie Pops
Perfectly suited for a fun family activity, these cookie pops are an excellent choice for Valentine’s Day celebrations. Packed with heart-shaped chocolate chip goodness, they’re transformed into tasty treats by simply adding a stick. Paint them with pink icing and decorate with multi-colored sprinkles for a festive finish that’s sure to delight both kids and adults alike!
Lemon Cake Mix Cookies
Rich in citrus flavor, these lemon bites are a delightful twist on traditional treats. Rather than relying on intense emotions to lift your spirits, try indulging in one of these bright and zesty cookies, and watch your mood soar. Remarkably, this innovative recipe transforms ordinary boxed cake mix into soft, pillowy cookies that dissolve effortlessly as you savor them. Not only do they boast a tantalizing crinkly exterior, but their airy interior makes for a truly satisfying experience.
Whether shared with loved ones or enjoyed on your own, these lemon bites are sure to bring a smile to your face and create special moments with those around you.
Red Velvet Cookie for Two
Virtually any tale of star-crossed lovers could benefit from the presence of this decadent red velvet cookie. The sweetness and delightfulness of this dessert would undoubtedly bring a sense of joy and happiness, rendering doom and despair unnecessary. Baked in a cast-iron skillet, this cookie is designed to be shared with others, fostering a spirit of camaraderie and conviviality.
When topped with rich chocolate syrup and an ample serving of ice cream, the romantic atmosphere that develops is truly palpable.
Valentine Sugar Wafer Cookies
Transforming your dessert game with ease, you’ll find that sometimes you crave the richness of gooey chocolate cookies, while other times, something light and airy will hit the spot. Toss aside the traditional cookie recipe and try these lovely wafers instead – perfect for a Valentine’s Day celebration or any romantic occasion.
They’re crafted by dipping delicate pink wafers into vibrant red candy melts, sprinkling with flair, and letting them chill until set, resulting in a delightfully simple yet sweet treat.
Strawberry Cake Mix Cookies
Sprinkling with pastel pink flair, these strawberry cake mix cookies exude a certain charm that’s hard to resist. Not only do they bake to crumbly perfection in just 10 minutes, but their compact size and adorable appearance make them the perfect sweet indulgence for any occasion. And let’s be honest, there’s no need to share them with anyone – sometimes the best way to celebrate Valentine’s Day is to treat yourself to a guilty pleasure.
Red Hot Cookies
Bursting with flavor and aroma, these ‘hot’ cookies are the perfect treat to get you in the mood for romance. With crushed Red Hot candies adding a spicy kick, they’re complemented by the warmth of cinnamon, creating a delightful combination. These sweet and savory cookies make an excellent gift idea – consider dusting them with sugar or sprinkling additional Red Hots on top for an added touch when presenting them to that special someone.
Valentine’s Day M&M Cookies
Recently, I’ve been experimenting with creative ways to repurpose holiday treats, and these colorful cookies have been a delightful discovery. Made with a simple vanilla cake mix as the base, they’re studded with M&Ms for an added pop of color and fun. Not only are they easy to prepare, but they also offer a great way to use up any leftover candy that’s been lingering in the house since Christmas.
Oreo Cookie Balls
Needless to say, if your partner is an Oreo enthusiast, you’ll want to give this recipe a try. What makes it so special is that it requires only three ingredients, making it effortless to whip up and show your love without breaking a sweat. After all, love shouldn’t be about hard work or complicated recipes – sometimes the simplest gestures can mean the most.
Raspberry Lemon Cookies
Aromatic and inviting, these refined cookies burst with vibrant fruity flavors that tantalize the taste buds. The tanginess of the lemon zest is thoughtfully paired with a subtle hint of sweetness from the raspberries, carefully balanced within a rich and buttery cookie texture.
Teddy Graham Valentine Conversation Heart Cookies
While these tiny teddy bears are undeniably adorable, it’s their accompanying details that truly make them stand out. Each one comes with a mini candy heart featuring endearing messages like ‘love you’ and ‘cutie’. This thoughtful touch is what elevates this treat to the next level – and the best part is, no baking or artistic skills are required to assemble these sweet gestures. In fact, the assembly process itself is remarkably easy, with zero cooking involved.
Heart Macarons With Lemon Buttercream
Not only does France have a reputation for being romantic, but they also excel at creating sweet treats that capture the heart. Nothing beats the combination of love and pastries, making this French-inspired recipe a perfect fit for Valentine’s Day. The macarons are made gorgeously fluffy and cut into perfect pink hearts, while a gooey layer of citrus-scented buttercream adds an extra touch of romance. It’s only a matter of time before you fall in love with every bite.
Laura Hauser is a food writer and editor passionate about authentic, approachable home cooking.
